魁省补贴联邦?联邦补贴魁省?

montreal

魁省补贴联邦?联邦补贴魁省?

---

实际上,这个问题没确切的官方数据.
引用非官方的统计数据,必须考虑各种因素,不能有意误导.
以09年为例
1.Federal Government Revenues Collected and Equalization Received
by Province 2009 – in $millions
Province
Federal Revenues Collected
$mn
Total Equalization 2008-09
$mn
NL 3,811 0
PEI 739 322
NS 5,034 1,495
NB 3,693 1,584
QC 39,677 8,028
ON 85,239 0
MB 6,453 2,063
SK 7,074 0
AB 35,990 0
BC 27,221 0
联邦在魁省征收 39.677, 返还8.028.

2.Federal Government Revenues and Expenditures by Province 2009
Province Federal Revenues Collected $mn Federal Expenditures $mn Difference $mn
NL 3,811 6,393 -2,582
PEI 739 1,942 -1,203
NS 5,034 12,200 -7,166
NB 3,693 8,662 -4,969
QC 39,677 53,318 -13,641
ON 85239 86,300 -1,061
MB 6,453 12,911 -6,458
SK 7,074 8,374 -1,300
AB 35,990 19,997 15,993
BC 27,221 27,232 -11
联邦在魁省征收39.677,支出53.318,看起来是魁省占了便宜,但实际上,在魁省支出的这部分,不仅仅是魁省的,也包括联邦设在魁省的各种设施,例如军事基地,人员等开支,和魁省人民无关,但却算在魁省头上了.